Skip to content

Guidebook XIV—An Interview with Dougald MacDonald

General News
  • How would you describe the scope of the work that goes into making the American Alpine Journal (AAJ)?

    Dougald MacDonald: Producing the AA J is a year-round effort that involves literally hundreds of people. The actual “staff” of the AAJ (who are all part-timers and volunteers) includes more than 15 people, and each year we work with roughly 300 individual climbers and photographers to share their stories.
    The book goes to press in late April, so the peak of the cycle is in March and April. But the work on the following year’s edition starts immediately, plus we prepare and upload online stories all year round. AND we produce The Cutting Edge podcast and the monthly Line newsletter.

    What’s the history of the AAJ? How has it changed over the years?

    DM: The AAJ is coming up on its 100th birthday, and unsurprisingly it has changed quite a lot over the years. It started out as much more of a Club publication, telling the stories of AAC members’ adventures. In the 1950s, with the rise of Himalayan climbing, the book started to become much more international. But it was really Ad Carter—who edited the AAJ for 35 years, starting in the 1960s—who created the wide-ranging, international publication it is today. We no longer focus mostly on the activities of AAC members—though we’re very happy to tell those stories when we can—but instead try to document all significant long routes and mountain exploration anywhere in the world, by climbers from every country.
    For both the AAJ and Accidents in North American Climbing (ANAC), the most significant changes of the last 10 to 15 years have been 1) the introduction of color photography throughout both books and 2) the launch of the searchable online database of every AAJ and ANAC article ever published.

    What’s an example of a unique challenge the editors have to deal with when making the AAJ?

    DM: One challenge is that we come out so long after many of the climbs actually happened. So, readers may have seen something about any given climb several times, in news reports and social media posts and even video productions. But the AAJ has never been in the breaking news business. Instead, we aim to provide perspective and context. Perspective in that we don’t have any vested interest that might slant a story one way or another, and context on the history and geography that helps readers really understand the significance of a climb, how it relates to what’s been done before, and what other opportunities might be out there. Another big challenge is language barriers, since we work with people from all over the world. We’re fortunate to work in English, which so many people around the world use these days. We also use skilled translators for some stories, and online translation tools have improved dramatically in recent years. But there’s still a lot of back-and-forth with authors to ensure we’re getting everything just right.

    What’s an example report that was really exciting for you to edit from the last few years?

    DM: For me, personally, the coolest stories are the ones that teach me about an area of the world—or a moment in climbing history—that I knew nothing about before starting to work on a story. In the upcoming book, for example, we have stories about winter climbing in Greece (who knew?) and a mountain range in Venezuela that’s gorgeous and has peaks over 16,000 feet. Unfortunately, that range is rapidly losing its snow cover and its small glaciers. AAJ senior editor Lindsay Griffin, who is editing the story, did some cool climbs in the range in 1985, and the difference between his photos and those from today is shocking.

    Are there any big differences in process between making the AAJ and ANAC?

    DM: The biggest differences are just the scale and scope of the two books: The AAJ is a nearly 400-page book that tries to cover the entir...


  • Sport ChannelS Sport Channel shared this topic on

Suggested topics


  • Blue Pill Or The Red Pill?

    Videos climbing
    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    26 Views
    EpicTVE
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itymXom_xrI
  • Yosemite Bans Flag Hanging on El Capitan

    General News climbing
    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    23 Views
    GrippedG
    Displaying flags on El Capitan and other Yosemite rock faces has historically served as a means of protest The post Yosemite Bans Flag Hanging on El Capitan appeared first on Gripped Magazine. https://gripped.com/news/yosemite-bans-flag-hanging-on-el-capitan/
  • Adam Ondra Tries Possible V18 Boulder

    General News climbing
    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    59 Views
    GrippedG
    V17 climber Camille Coudert has put in over 100 sessions on Imotep Assis - a problem that could possible be V18 The post Adam Ondra Tries Possible V18 Boulder appeared first on Gripped Magazine. https://gripped.com/news/adam-ondra-tries-possible-v18-boulder/
  • Sonnie Trotter Climbing The Path 5.14R

    General News climbing
    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    35 Views
    GrippedG
    The challenging gear route was first climbed nearly 20 years ago. The first ascensionist just dropped the original FA video on YouTube The post Sonnie Trotter Climbing The Path 5.14R appeared first on Gripped Magazine. https://gripped.com/profiles/sonnie-trotter-climbing-the-path-5-14r/
  • 0 Votes
    1 Posts
    42 Views
    GrippedG
    We hear from Babsi Zangerl who just made the first-ever no-fall ascent of a free route on El Capitan The post Babsi Zangerl Talks About Her Historic Flash of Freerider on El Capitan appeared first on Gripped Magazine. https://gripped.com/profiles/babsi-zangerl-talks-about-her-historic-flash-of-freerider-on-el-capitan/
  • 0 Votes
    1 Posts
    148 Views
    American Alpine ClubA
    By: Byron Harvison, AAC General Counsel and Advocacy Director First ascents are usually full of surprises. That’s why we love doing them. It takes every bit of your skill and experience to navigate all the known and unknown challenges the route throws at you. Like a FA, the first-of-its-kind EXPLORE Act Recreation Package is presenting challenges and proving there is more work to put in.   You may recall that the EXPLORE Act (Expanding Public Lands Outdoor Recreation Experiences) was unanimously passed in the House last April after being introduced by Representative Westerman (R-AR) and Representative Grijalva (D-AZ).  It contains several pieces of legislation deeply impacting recreation. The Simplifying Outdoor Access for Recreation Act (SOAR) has been a priority for the AAC and partner organizations such as the AMGA, Outdoor Alliance, and The Mountaineers for 10 years. It updates and streamlines recreational permitting for guides, making the outdoors more accessible. EXPLORE also includes the Protecting America’s Rock Climbing Act (PARC), which the AAC and Access Fund have collaborated on extensively, that will help safeguard the historic use and maintenance of fixed anchors in Wilderness, and reaffirms the appropriateness of climbing on public lands. Other elements in the package include the BOLT Act, making FICOR (the Federal Interagency Council on Outdoor Recreation) permanent as well as the Outdoor Recreation Legacy Partnership, Recreation Not Red Tape, and several pieces of legislation impacting outdoor infrastructure.   During our most recent visit to DC in September, in conjunction with the celebration of Outdoor Alliance’s 10th Anniversary, we teamed up to urge Senators to find floor time to pass EXPLORE as a stand alone bill or to attach it to must-pass legislation such as the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). Unfortunately, EXPLORE did not make it into the NDAA’s Manager’s Amendment, which exhausts that route for passage.   Congress has been preoccupied with funding the federal government, resulting in a (now typical) Continuing Resolution to fund the government at the current levels until December 20th. Given the dynamics of it being an election year and certain change of leadership, and the impacts of a lame duck session, it is quite difficult to predict exactly how EXPLORE may be able to pass this Congress. One potential scenario is that it may be grouped in with a larger year-end lands package, which can be a good thing, but could be complicated given the varied political motivations of legislators post-election. With the strong bipartisan and bicameral support of EXPLORE we are hopeful that we can find a path to secure the passage of the recreation package this Congress regardless of the outcome of the election.  One thing is for sure, there are no guarantees. Just as the summit is never guaranteed in climbing, no piece of legislation is a sure thing. We will continue to push forward and put the work in, one foot after another, and see it through. https://americanalpineclub.org/news/2024/10/10/a-long-and-winding-road-an-update-on-the-explore-recreation-package
  • 0 Votes
    1 Posts
    62 Views
    ClimbingZineC
    A conversation with Taylor Luneau. Taylor discovered climbing after an injury derailed his ice hockey career. Taylor and Luke have a wide ranging conversation from local climbing organizations to the relationship of climate change and ice climbing, and much more. Plus in the outro is the premiere of the poem 5.6+ from the upcoming Microdose…<hr /><p><a href="https://climbingzine.com/from-the-ice-rink-to-the-ice-climb-with-taylor-luneau/">https://climbingzine.com/from-the-ice-rink-to-the-ice-climb-with-taylor-luneau/</a>
  • David Fitzgerald Sends Shawn Raboutou’s Big Z V16

    General News climbing
    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    55 Views
    GrippedG
    https://gripped.com/news/david-fitzgerald-sends-shawn-raboutous-big-z-v16/